Greatest Gangster Movies Set in New York City: Crime Thrillers You Need to See

New York City has long been the backdrop for some of the most iconic and gripping gang-related films in cinematic history. From the mean streets of The Bronx to the gritty neighborhoods of Brooklyn, these movies have captured the essence of urban life and the complexities of gang culture. In this article, we will explore the best New York City gang movies that have left an indelible mark on the silver screen. From the thrilling action to the raw and emotional storytelling, these films have taken audiences on a rollercoaster ride through the world of street gangs, showcasing the allure, danger, and struggles of life in the underbelly of the city that never sleeps. Get ready to delve into a world of loyalty, betrayal, and adrenaline-pumping drama as we count down the top NYC gang movies of all time ever!

Timeless Love & Turf Wars! West Side Story (1961)

The original film of West Side Story was released in 1961 and directed by Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins, is a musical film based on Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. The famous soundtrack features music by Leonard Bernstein and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim. Starring Natalie Wood, Rita Moreno, George Chakris, Russ Tamblyn, and Richard Beymer, the film was a tremendous success, becoming the highest-grossing film of 1961. It garnered an impressive ten (10) Oscars, including Best Picture, and Rita Moreno won Best Supporting Actress, making her the first Latina woman to receive an Academy Award. However, the film has faced deserved criticism for whitewashing certain characters and for elements that have not aged well. While some song-and-dance numbers remain landmarks of musical theater history, the portrayal of non-threatening gangs — which Roger Ebert said were “like bad-boy Archies and Jugheads” — erases them of all true tension and danger, and despite Rita Moreno’s well-deserved accolades, the stereotypical portrayals and cultural appropriation here evoke many cringes. But hey! 🎼 When you’re a Jet you. Stay. A. Jettttt! 🎼

Click on the cowboy to buy West Side Story (1961)!

Antebellum Urban Turmoil! Gangs of New York (2002)

The historical epic crime drama Gangs of New York (2002) was directed by Martin Scorsese — that genius behind Goodfellas, After Hours, and Bringing Out the Dead — delves into the fierce rivalry between two gangs, the nativist Natives and the Irish immigrant Dead Rabbits, set in 19th-century Lower Manhattan during the Civil War era. The film centers on Amsterdam Vallon’s (handsome person Leonardo Dicaprio) quest for vengeance against Bill the Butcher (fantastic scenery-chewer Daniel Day-Lewis), leader of the Natives, following the murder of Amsterdam’s father. Amidst the backdrop of social unrest and immigration struggles, the movie portrays a gritty and chaotic urban landscape where power, revenge, and identity collide — while the rich and well-off participated in poverty tourism. Gangs of New York is indeed an epic tale of gangs in New York City, blending historical accuracy with Scorsese’s distinct storytelling and period details, even though some critics have noted certain fictionalized elements that may impact its overall authenticity. However, many characters are based on very influential real-life figures like William “Boss” Tweed, Horace Greeley, and P.T. Barnum, and those interested in New York City’s colorful history will find Gangs of New York an excellent starting point in learning more about how life was like in this part of the world at that point in time.

Click on NYC to buy Gangs of New York (2002)!

Walter Hill Reinterprets Homer with The Warriors (1979)

Walter Hill is a visionary filmmaker known for his gripping storytelling, distinctive style, and contributions to the genres of action, crime, and western films. The Warriors (1979) may be his most popular and well-known. The film presents a modern-day parallel to the ancient Greek epic The Odyssey by Homer. Just as Odysseus and his companions faced a perilous journey back to their homeland, The Warriors follows a gang of Coney Island, New York City, trying to make their way back home after being wrongly accused by rival gangs of a murder they didn’t commit. This gripping urban adventure mirrors the timeless themes of courage, survival, and brotherhood found in Homer’s epic tale. The film’s portrayal of the gang’s encounters with rival factions and various challenges throughout the city represents the trials and tribulations faced by Odysseus and his crew during their voyage. Walter Hill’s reimagining of The Odyssey through the lens of a 1970s street gang resonates with audiences, showcasing the enduring power of ancient mythology in modern storytelling.

Click on the spartan to buy The Warriors (1979)!

Nostalgic Journey thru 1950s Brooklyn: Exploring the Endearing Coming-of-Age Tale of The Lords of Flatbush (1974)

Hey, remember that time when Fonzie and Rocky starred in a movie together? The Lords of Flatbush is a coming-of-age film released in 1974, directed by Martin Davidson and Stephen Verona. Set in the 1950s, the movie revolves around a group of four Brooklyn teenagers: Chico, Stanley, Butchey, and Wimpy. The friends navigate the challenges of adolescence, love, and dreams against the backdrop of their working-class neighborhood, Flatbush, Brooklyn. However clunky, film captures the essence of the 1950s era with its nostalgic portrayal of teenage life and highlights universal themes of friendship, loyalty, and the desire to break free from the limitations of their environment. Featuring young actors who later became famous in their careers, including Sylvester Stallone and Henry Winkler, The Lords of Flatbush offers that raw aesthetic of 1970s American low-budget independent filmmaking with its glimpse into the struggles and dreams of working-class youth in a bygone era.

Click on the Manhattan Bridge to buy The Lords of Flatbush (1974)!

Consequences of the Crack Epidemic: New Jack City (1991)

Released in 1991 and directed by Mario Van Peebles, New Jack City not only serves as a gripping crime drama but also offers a social commentary on the impact of the crack epidemic on urban communities, reflecting the harsh realities faced by those affected by drug abuse and violence. The movie takes place in the drug-infested streets of Harlem, New York City, during the crack epidemic of the late 1980s and early 1990s. Accompanied by a riveting hip-hop soundtrack, the film follows the rise and fall of drug lord Nino Brown, played by Wesley Snipes, as he builds a powerful drug empire known as the Cash Money Brothers. Ice-T stars as Scotty Appleton, a dedicated undercover detective determined to bring Nino Brown down and put an end to the drug-related violence plaguing the city. The film remains influential, and Lil Wayne named his Tha Carter records after the building in the film.

Click on Harlem to buy New Jack City (1991)!

Power & Crime in the Concrete Jungle: King of New York (1990)

A loaded cast — featuring Christopher Walken, Laurence Fishburne, Wesley Snipes, Giancarlo Esposito, Steve Buscemi, and Theresa Randle — fleshes out Abel Ferrara’s noir-ish vision of crime-filled New York City in King of New York (1990). Christopher Walken stars as Frank White, a powerful drug lord recently released from prison. Upon his return to the streets of New York City, Frank aspires to reclaim his criminal empire and re-establish himself as a gang lord to be reckoned with. As he navigates the dangerous world of drug trafficking, Frank’s character becomes more complex, as he seeks to balance his ruthless criminal activities with a desire to invest in social programs to benefit the community. While not a commercial success upon its initial release, King of New York has gained a cult following over the years for its stylish direction, gritty storytelling, and its exploration of complex moral dilemmas. The film has been praised for its unique portrayal of a crime lord with a conscience, as well as its gritty depiction of New York City during the late 1980s and early 1990s. King of New York remains a noteworthy entry in the crime thriller genre, showcasing Abel Ferrara’s distinctive filmmaking style and Christopher Walken’s memorable performance as the enigmatic Frank White. The film continues to be appreciated for its dark and thought-provoking take on the criminal underworld and the struggle for power.

Click on the king to buy King of New York (1990)!

The Moral Crossroads of Mean Streets (1973)

Naturally, a filmmaker so entrenched in New York City like Martin Scorcese would have another movie on this list. Mean Streets (1973) is set in New York City’s Little Italy neighborhood, the movie follows Charlie, played by Harvey Keitel, a small-time debt collector for his uncle’s loan-sharking business, and his reckless and unpredictable friend, Johnny Boy, portrayed by Robert De Niro. As Charlie struggles to balance his responsibilities and his loyalty to Johnny Boy, he grapples with the moral dilemmas of his environment and his own identity. The film delves into themes of guilt, redemption, and the clash between personal morality and the demands of the criminal underworld. Mean Streets showcases Scorsese’s signature filmmaking style, with its raw and unfiltered portrayal of New York City’s streets and its characters. The film is regarded as a pivotal work in Scorsese’s career and remains a quintessential example of early 1970s American cinema.

Click on the meanie to buy Mean Streets (1973)!

We told an AI to mash up all of the movies mentioned in this post and this is what happened.

Weird, huh?

Read more of our movie content below!

Ready for an adventure like no other? 🚲🎬 Dive into the world of Facts & Trivia About Pee Wee’s Big Adventure! 🌟🍿

Discover Facts about Paul Newman in Cool Hand Luke for a cool cinematic experience like no other ❄️🎬🌟

As long as we are on the subject of that iconic movie star, see our list of Facts & Trivia About Handsome Bastard Actor Philanthropist Paul Newman. 🍿 🎬

You should also read our list of Facts & Trivia About Searching for Bobby Fischer, the greatest chess movie ever made.

Eric Roberts and Mickey Rourke are two of the best actors of their generation. Check out our list of Facts & Trivia About The Pope of Greenwich Village!

Cover Image Credit: Image by Noel from Pixabay

*****This post contains affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something we may earn a commission. Thank you for reading Content Bash!*****